Exploring economic inequality  -  Advocating for the bottom 50%

Click here to follow on Twitter

News, Events & Opinions

5 ways Joe Biden can advance his tax agenda (without a Senate majority) - MarketWatch

Effects of Welfare Reform on Parenting - Nancy Reichman, Hope Corman, Dhaval M. Dave, Ariel Kalil & Ofira Schwartz-Soicher/NBER

"We found that welfare reform had adverse effects on engagement in parent-child activities, children feeling close to their mothers, and mothers knowing their children’s whereabouts, with the effects generally concentrated among boys. These findings have implications for children’s development and contribute to a virtually non-existent literature on the effects of welfare reform on parenting and the small but growing economic literature on parenting."

This new research begins to fill a void left by DC think tanks "bipartisan" enthusiasm for the 1996 welfare reform bill. Did TANF go too far in incentivizing work over raising kids?  A single parent working a couple low-wage jobs has little time and energy to invest in life at home.  Policymakers should take care that childcare/work trade-offs and incentives are balanced.  A higher minimum wage could provide greater work incentive than kicking people off of welfare, and combine well with an expanded child tax credit targeted to low-income households.

"In August 2017, Russian enforcers forced Google to implement a well-designed choice screen, meaning that users of mobile phones were given a screen where they would select a search engine without being defaulted to using Google. Google search competitor Yandex immediately began gaining share, as the chart (above) shows."

Could Google Soon Face... Competition? Antitrust action tends to force competition into the market, even without a victory. - Matt Stoller

"One of the keys to the Department of Justice antitrust suit against Google is Google’s payment to Apple to let its search engine serve as the default on iPhone Safari browser. The two companies share revenue on Google searches done on iPhones, iPads, and Macs, which reportedly amounts to $8-12 billion a year in the U.S."

Is the Google/Apple deal a tying arrangement?  An IT era form of vertical duopoly?  Actionable?  Where are the boundaries between markets?

What is a Duopoly?

What Are the Elements of a Per Se Illegal Tying Claim Under the Antitrust Laws?

Pope Francis prays for Maradona

"Born in grinding poverty, Maradona lifted himself up by his bootstraps, mesmerizing opponents and earning the respect of sports fans the world over."

Diego Maradona, mesmerizing soccer star and Argentine legend, dies at 60

"Peerless on the soccer pitch, Mr. Maradona was profligate and profane off it. A self-proclaimed champion of the poor, he led a lifestyle of toxic excess. He was ejected from the 1994 World Cup after testing positive for the performance-enhancing drug ephedrine. And his two-decade addiction to cocaine landed him in a mental institution for a time and twice took him to the brink of death.

"Mr. Maradona’s faith and politics were no less controversial. He was a Roman Catholic who said he was disappointed by his meeting with Pope John Paul II, telling reporters: “I was in the Vatican and I saw all these golden ceilings and afterwards I heard the Pope say the Church was worried about the welfare of poor kids. Sell your ceiling then, amigo, do something!”

"He counted two daughters as his legitimate children and characterized the others he sired during stays in Italy and Cuba as “a product of my money and mistakes.”

"Granted haven by Fidel Castro in 2000 to confront his drug dependency, Mr. Maradona believed he owed his life to the Cuban people and to Castro, whose likeness was tattooed on his left calf, and he proclaimed himself a disciple of the Argentine-born guerrilla leader Ernesto “Che” Guevara, whose face was tattooed on his right biceps."

Maradona Goal of the Century - Víctor Hugo Morales commentary - Argentina-England 2-1 1986 - YouTube

After Winslow Homer, Thanksgiving in Camp, published 1862, National Gallery of Art

Abraham Lincoln’s Thanksgiving Proclamation - Oct. 3, 1863

Three months after pivotal Union army victories at Gettysburg and Vicksburg, President Lincoln proclaimed the last Thursday of November would be an annual day of thanksgiving and national healing.  Prompted by years of campaigning by writer and activist Sarah Josepha Hale, the Oct. 3 1863 proclamation was written by Secretary of State William Seward. 

"...I do, therefore, invite my fellow-citizens in every part of the United States, and also those who are at sea and those who are sojourning in foreign lands, to set apart and observe the last Thursday of November next as a Day of Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the heavens. And I recommend to them that, while offering up the ascriptions justly due to Him for such singular deliverances and blessings, they do also, with humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience, commend to His tender care all those who have become widows, orphans, mourners, or sufferers in the lamentable civil strife in which we are unavoidably engaged, and fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty hand to heal the wounds of the nation, and to restore it, as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes, to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquility, and union."

Sketch by Alfred Waud of Thanksgiving in camp (of General Louis Blenker) during the U.S. Civil War in 1861

America’s Food Banks Are Totally Overwhelmed Right Now - Bridget Read/The Cut

Find Your Local Food Bank - Feeding America

The list of food banks on this site is not comprehensive  One one can call the the regional food bank the site provides and ask if there are options closer to where you live.

'Hillbilly Elegy' turns J.D. Vance's memoir into a dreary movie - Brian Lowry/CNN

True enough.  Ron Howard's adaptation lacks most of the nuance and detailed fabric of Vance's book.  Good acting by Glenn Close and Amy Adams but the plot line oversimplified and cliche. The central "character" of the book, in effect, was a remembered tableau of dysfunctional life in Hillbilly-dom.  The movie settles for a soapy moral assessment of a few characters. Too many frames of Yale law school -- not enough of the hollows and Rust Belt. Somehow left out was the funeral scene where the grandparents conduct an armed search of all the guests' vehicles to find a missing grandchild they mistakenly conclude must have been abducted by a sex pervert.  Here's the passage from Chapter 7:

“I thought about a moment nearly a decade earlier that I’d heard about but didn’t remember. I was four or five, sitting in a church pew for a great-uncle’s funeral in that same Deaton funeral home in Jackson. We had just arrived after a long drive from Middletown, and when the minister asked us to bow our heads and pray, I bowed my head and passed out. Mamaw’s older brother Uncle Pet lay me on my side with a Bible as a pillow and thought nothing more of it. I was asleep for what happened next, but I’ve heard some version of it a hundred times. Even today, when I see someone who attended that funeral, they tell me about my hillbilly Mamaw and Papaw.

“When I failed to appear in the crowd of mourners leaving the church, Mamaw and Papaw grew suspicious. There were perverts even in Jackson, they told me, who wanted to stick sticks up your butt and “blow on your pecker” as much as the perverts in Ohio or Indiana or California. Papaw hatched a plan: There were only two exits to Deaton’s, and no one had driven away yet. Papaw ran to the car and grabbed a .44 Magnum for himself and a .38 Special for Mamaw. They manned the exits to the funeral home and checked every car. When they encountered an old friend, they explained the situation and enlisted help. When they met someone else, they searched the cars like goddamned DEA agents.

“Uncle Pet approached, frustrated that Mamaw and Papaw were holding up traffic. When they explained, Pet howled with laughter: “He’s asleep in the church pew, let me show you.” After they found me, they allowed traffic to flow freely once again.”

Bidding War for Nurses; Cutting Quarantine Time; 'Out of Control Fire' - Judy George/MedPage Today

FEDERAL SOCIAL SAFETY NET PROGRAMS: Millions of Full-Time Workers Rely on Federal Health Care and Food Assistance Programs - GAO

The availability of Medicaid, food stamps, and the EITC is wired into employers' wage strategies.  Upping the minimum wage could significantly reduce the cost of these public programs, albeit with some job loss if not tailored to variation regional labor markets.

Opposing Racism and Human Bondage in the United States - Center on Capital & Social Equity

Policy recommendations:

- Encourage intermarriage, both between people of different ethnic backgrounds and economic classes.

- Progressive economic and tax policies applied equitably across all groups.

- Vigorous enforcement of civil rights and anti-discrimination standards.

- Color-blind policies to lift the growing underclass.

Race-neutral Economics Helps Minority Communities - CCSE

This op-ed was accepted for publication by a Washington daily newspaper but not printed because a draft  had been  posted on this web site.  Wow - didn't know that many people were paying attention! 

For interracial couples, Kamala Harris and Doug Emhoff are a ‘monumental’ symbol - WaPo

Interracial marriage in the United States - Wikipedia

L.A. County suspends outdoor dining at restaurants as coronavirus surges - L.A. Times

“What do I think of it? It’s horrible. It’s another punch,” said Michael Simhai, the owner of Della Terra, an Italian restaurant in the Fairfax district, about 10 minutes after learning of the moratorium on outdoor dining.

“It will be horrible for my staff,” said Simhai, noting that his takeout business would not offset the loss from patrons dining on his restaurant’s patios. “All the busboys, food runners, servers — they are not needed…. They work paycheck to paycheck. What we are going to do?”

As Secretary of State Mike Pompeo visits the West Bank, a Palestinian writer recalls being evicted by Israeli settlers - MSNBC

Eight mayors: We need a Marshall Plan for Middle America - William PedutoJamael Tito BrownNan WhaleyAndrew GintherJohn CranleySteve WilliamsRon Dulaney Jr. and Greg Fischer

Invest in a network of renewable energy R&D and manufacturing in coal country?  Worth a try.  What could go wrong?

If commie Joe Stalin managed to mass produce a working man's champagne, why couldn't a capitalist Appalachia help produce clean energy? 

How Stalin and the Soviet Union Created a Champagne for the Working Class

We demand immediate COVID relief, a smooth and open transition of power and moral policies that guarantee universal health care, raise wages and fight chronic inequality in the first 100 days of the next administration. -

Poor People's Campaign

To: The Trump administration, the 116th and 117th U.S. Congress, elected and incoming governors and state legislators and the Biden-Harris transition team

On November 23 at 2:30pm ET, the Poor People’s Campaign will organize national caravans to mourn the many thousands gone, to demand a smooth and open transition of power and to lift up the moral policies we need immediately and in the first days of the new administration.

Thanks to Revs. Barber and Theoharis for their leadership.

Add your name

The next cliff: Millions of jobless Americans risk losing aid - Janelle Marte/Reuters

Decades before the Vatican’s McCarrick report, there was a mother on a secret mission - Michelle Boorstein/WaPo

"It was a sunny day in the 1980s, Mother 1 told investigators, when she packed up special pens and paper and envelopes, got into the family car and sneaked away. Telling no one, the homemaker drove more than an hour to the library branch near the bishop’s residence in Metuchen, N.J., where McCarrick then lived. There, she handwrote anonymous warnings about the inappropriate touching of boys, then mailed them to every U.S. cardinal and to the Vatican’s ambassador in the United States."

Jesus Criticizes the Religious Leaders - Matthew 23 - New Living Translation

Canceling Student Loan Debt Is Poor Economic Stimulus - Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget

How to Fix the Covid Stimulus Payment Problem: Accounts, Information, and Infrastructure - Aaron Klein/Brookings

Steven Mnuchin’s Finest Hour: Treasury chief decides to end Fed emergency programs as Congress intended. - WSJ

Whoever ends up with those billions, they should be targeted to people needing $$ for food and rent.  Financial sector doesn't need any more subsidy or reinsurance. 

Could new tools allowing the Fed to pump money through ‘the people’ make U.S. monetary policy more equitable and effective? - Center on Capital & Social Equity

The Trump administration is hampering the economic recovery at a critical time - Heather Long/WaPo

"Treasury Secretary Mnuchin is curbing the Fed’s powers is the latest blow to an economy that’s limping along with few supports left after Dec. 31."

Presidential inauguration: when will Joe Biden take over the White House? - AS English

Art of the Deal? Last offer: Let him keep his crap in the WH 'til the end of the month if he concedes now, unblocks the  transition.

Apple said to be among US companies lobbying against Uighur forced labor bill - Apple Insider

Worldwide Capitalism's Daily Devotion: "Buy low, sell high." 

Research question: How does the quality of products made by slaves in China compare with that of comparable workers who get paid and have more freedom?

Better jobs, longer working lives: Proposals to improve the low-wage labor market for older workers - Beth Truesdale/Brookings

The real ‘Queen’s Gambit’: Meet the first woman to qualify for the World Chess Championship - P.J. Grisar/Forward

The lowest-paid workers in higher education are suffering the highest job losses - WaPo

Don't expect much research and analysis on the fairness of the Ivory Tower's medieval political economics. Tenured profs enjoy guild protections. For workers on the lower rungs, there's the free market for labor.

"Custodian Bill Rosser, 48, was one of 139 support staff at Ohio University whose positions were eliminated in the first of three rounds of layoffs beginning in May. His wife, son and uncle all lost their jobs at the public university. Although his wife has since been rehired in culinary services, she earns less than before and is now supporting a family of four on one paycheck. The couple went from making $68,000 a year to about $30,000."

Giuliani Has Hair Dye Malfunction During Trump Lawsuit Press Conference | The Tonight Show - YouTube

Will Rudy be DT's sidekick on the new talk show? 

America Should Rewrite the China Trade Contract - Arvind Subramanian

TPP 2 and what?

Cares Act Charitable Tax Planning Opportunities for 2020 - Harvard University

"If you itemize deductions:

  • You can deduct up to 100 percent of your adjusted gross income (AGI) for gifts of cash in 2020—up from 60 percent in 2019.

"For example, a donor with an AGI of $1 million could donate $1 million in cash to Harvard and receive a federal income tax deduction of $1 million.

  • This time-limited benefit only applies to gifts to Harvard or other public charities. It is not applicable to gifts to donor-advised funds (DAFs) or supporting organizations.*
  • The 100 percent limit is reduced dollar-for-dollar by other itemized charitable deductions. This means that in 2020, a donor who deducts 30 percent of their AGI in long-term appreciated property gifts will be able to also deduct up to 70 percent of AGI for qualified cash gifts—a total deduction of up to 100 percent of AGI.

"If you take the standard deduction:

  • Under the CARES Act, a donor may claim up to $300 in charitable deductions in 2020. The deduction is taken “above the line,” which means that it reduces a donor’s AGI, resulting in a decreased tax burden.

*Examples of supporting organizations are charitable trusts that benefit a public charity or fundraising foundations for a school or hospital."

Gifts That Pay You Income

How Much Are Most Colleges Paying in Endowment Tax? - Inside Higher Ed

"Colleges and universities generally aren't happy about the endowment tax, but many are paying less than the tens of millions of dollars reported by the country's wealthiest universities, a review finds. And even those ultrawealthy universities might end up paying substantially less."

Dear Congress:  Need a few $$ to plug a hole?  Endowment taxes could be broader and higher.

12 million to lose federal unemployment benefits after Christmas: study - The Hill

As Thanksgiving Approaches, Fewer Than Half of Households With Kids Very Confident About Affording Needed Food - CBPP

Dems send Pompeo letter demanding information on Palestinian village demolition

Marian Wright Edelman: Millionaires and billionaires keep winning and poor children keep losing - Philadelphia Tribune

The number of 401(k) and TSP millionaires grows even as some workers are forced to tap their retirement account because of economic impacts of the pandemic. - Michelle Singletary

How the American Retirement Savings System Magnifies Wealth Inequality - Karl Polzer/Society of Actuaries

Elements of the employee benefit industry disputed the assertions made in the above essay written four years ago.  What do you think?

Belgium vowed to protect nursing homes from covid-19. Deaths there are still among the worst in the world. - Washington Post

As in NY state and other parts of the US, hospitals' political clout -- along with societal neglect and lack of urgency by many  LTC providers and gov authorities -- has contributed to high number of nursing home deaths in Belgium.  As repeated often on this site in the spring and summer: Test, test, test, test...Not over until it's over.

July 1, 2020 - Its past time the White House and Congress required, and funded, comprehensive Covid testing in nursing homes - Center on Capital & Social Equity

Report: Belgian nursing homes failed patients amid pandemic - AP

Sweden, having refused to lock down, is now bringing in tougher COVID-19 restrictions as cases and deaths soar. 'This is the new norm,' the prime minister said. - Business Insider

In Sweden, black queen moves to middle of the board.

Seventh Seal - Renegade Cut/YouTube


Wealth taxes in foreign countries - UK Wealth Tax Commission

Devil's in the details.

Letters to Kamala: What the vice president-elect’s victory means to these Pittsburgh-area Black and Brown girls

Can Mitch McConnell do the right thing just once? - E.J. Dionne Jr./Washington Post

With Trump's departure, the center of power in the Republican Party shifts from the White House to McConnell. Senate leader should focus 'stimulus' on lower-income Americans most in need.

A wall of money is ready for the post-pandemic economy - Julia Horowitz/CNN

We’re being left behind’: Rural hospitals can’t afford ultra-cold freezers to store the leading Covid-19 vaccine - Olivia Goldhill/Stat

Footnotes on capitalism:  The Poor Man's Hedge Fund recently shifted investment $$ from a company making coffins and urns to one making medical freezers.  Last week, the former fared better in the equities market. Both appear well managed.

In the long run, better to follow the counsel of Graham and Buffett.  Forget about second guessing the Invisible Hand.

A Wall Street tax that could lift many out of poverty already exists. It's just not being collected - AlterNet

As proposed in this op-ed, a small national equity transaction tax could fund a universal savings and investment system that would help lower-income people be much better prepared for old age and emergency expenses.

Inclusive capitalism = All workers own working capital, and share in profits, economic growth, and rents.

Changes that Would Make a Difference in the Biden Administration - Dean Baker

Biden Fills Economic Posts With Experts on Systemic Racism - Bloomberg

To the victors, the policy jobs.  Will Biden's econ czars focus only on low-income people of certain skin color and gender?   Or treat all poor people the same?  Talk with Rev. Barber.

If the argument for fairness doesn't resonate, it might be wise, at minimum, to recall the politics of Reconstruction and decades of resulting backlash. 

100 Bible Verses about Rich Exploiting The Poor

What did the ancients say?  Which ones resonate today?

James 2:2-6 ESV: "For if a man wearing a gold ring and fine clothing comes into your assembly, and a poor man in shabby clothing also comes in, and if you pay attention to the one who wears the fine clothing and say, “You sit here in a good place,” while you say to the poor man, “You stand over there,” or, “Sit down at my feet,” have you not then made distinctions among yourselves and become judges with evil thoughts? Listen, my beloved brothers, has not God chosen those who are poor in the world to be rich in faith and heirs of the kingdom, which he has promised to those who love him? But you have dishonored the poor man. Are not the rich the ones who oppress you, and the ones who drag you into court?"

Businesses brace for mandatory workplace safety rules under Biden - Politico

"Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and other Republicans are demanding a robust liability shield for businesses and schools as a condition for a new aid package — a provision that former OSHA officials say would strip Biden of the ability to enforce Covid-19 workplace protections."

How will how the assisted living and nursing home industries weigh in on this set of issues involving trade-offs between worker/resident safety and profitability?

California’s gig worker initiative blew a giant hole in its landmark labor law. What’s left? - Sacramento Bee

Fiscal Policy for the COVID-19 Economy: discussion with Mark Mazur - Tax Policy Center

Why choose between expanding the EITC and refundable child tax credit?  Do both.  The policies support different types of low-income households. We should both  encourage work and make sure families can afford to raise their kids.  And raise the minimum wage.

World Bank plan to furlough food service workers spurs backlash - WaPo

Question of Moral Philosophy:  Would these high-paid economists and the contractor take a smaller raise/profit margin to help the idled food workers get by? Or are we only talking about other people's money?

How to Deter Corporate Crime Like We Mean It - John C. Coffee, Jr. /Project Syndicate

Interesting idea for corporate equity fines to deter criminal behavior without punishing workers and impairing company operations.  C Suite, other corporate decision makers, shareholders/owners, and board members all need to have skin in the game.

Elizabeth Warren wants CEOs to go to jail when their companies behave badly - Vox

"Warren introduced new bills to hold executives more accountable for corporate misconduct."

Warren for Justice?

Comprehensive Criminal Justice Reform - Warren Democrats

Their coronavirus vaccine candidate has made them billionaires. This modest German Turkish couple doesn’t own a car. - WaPo

Infectious-Disease Expert Urges For Caution Over Pfizer's Vaccine. Here's Why

OCD Drug Looks Promising for COVID-19 Outpatients — Pilot trial finds lack of clinical deterioration, but larger studies needed

‘The party is pushing back’: why Beijing reined in Jack Ma and Ant - Financial Times

Weakening US  Economy, Widespread Hardship Show Urgent Need for Further Relief - CBPP

Stimulus deal: Where things stand now that the Senate is back in session - c/net

President Donald J. Trump Is Working to Stop Evictions and Protect Americans’ Homes During the COVID-19 Pandemic - White House Fact Sheet

Dear U.S. Presidents and Congress:

The number of Americans needing help to get food and pay the rent continues rising.  Time to put your heads together and pass more "stimulus" legislation.

BTW, a couple things: 1) If he doesn't move out by the end of January, it might be best just to cut off the water and electricity and have Biden live somewhere else for a while. Less drama that way. Melania won't put up with the smell in the bathrooms for long. And, if he wants to come back in 2024, it doesn't make sense to leave a mess. 2) Also, be on the lookout for last-minute changes to legislation adding eviction protections for senior elected officials.

Who Owns US Stock? Foreigners and Rich Americans - Tax Policy Center

Pfizer Vaccine Timeline - Future of Capitalism

November surprise?  If true, can you blame the 'Deep State'? 

After Boosting Low-Income Voter Turnout, Poor People’s Campaign Mobilizes for Covid Relief - Inequality.org

Keep the tough approach or seek cooperation? China looms large for Biden. - John Pomfret - Washington Post

A special undercover report from China’s secretive Xinjiang region - FRONTLINE

"The Communist regime’s mass imprisonment of Muslims, and its use and testing of sophisticated surveillance technology against the Uyghur community."

Vile.  The world's largest ethnic majority experiments with mass high-tech surveillance, detention, forced labor, and terror to cleanse an ethnic minority and bend it into China's totalitarian 'communo-capitalist' system.  Who's next?

The West may end up paying a heavy price for 30 years of cheap Chinese labor and goods both domestically - with a resulting large, disaffected underclass - and in terms of international competition. 

China ups scrutiny of tech giants with draft anti-monopoly rules - Reuters

Why?  Making sure markets work for Chinese consumers?  Optics while party bosses make sure they get their cut?  Result of rival factions?

Jason Furman and Joshua Wright Debate: Do Digital Platforms Require a New Regulatory Regime? -  Technology Policy Institute


CCSE comment:  Biden's plans for a major tax policy shift and higher minimum wage would help low-paid workers.  But will he reverse Trump's policy of stemming the inflow of unskilled, cheap labor, which weakens their bargaining position?  It's possibly one reason Trump got more Latino votes along the Rio Grande in 2020.  D's need to dig down on the economics of inequality and opportunity, and ditch identity politics. How much can Biden get through the Senate?  How much without Congress?

A Tale Of Two Tax Policies: Trump Rewards Wealth, Biden Rewards Work

Joe Biden is doubling down on raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour despite the economic downturn. It could bump paychecks for over 27 million workers.

An Updated Analysis of Former Vice President Biden's Tax Proposals

Why Texas’s overwhelmingly Latino Rio Grande Valley turned toward Trump

Chart: How U.S. Latinos Voted in the 2020 Presidential Election

Still Playing Immigration Piñata?

Apple Freezes New Business for Pegatron on China Labor Abuse - Bloomberg

The too-muchness of Donald Trump - David Von Drehle/WaPo

Yesterday's fish 'n chips in the White House.  Next... Make room for "24/7 joe with the Donald"?  In short run, how can the Poor Man's Hedge Fund capitalize on wave of media $$ heading for Georgia?

President-Elect Biden Has A Plan To Combat COVID-19. Here's What's In It - NPR

Get on top of Covid (test, vaccinate, treat, cover).  Revive the economy.  Share the wealth.  Meanwhile, help people get food and pay the rent.

What we owe to Donald J Trump - Branko Milanovic

Trump as the ultimate triumph of neoliberalism

Art After the Plague: How painters through the ages have responded to contagion, pestilence, and deadly epidemics - Ingrid Rowland/American Scholar

How World War II Vets Won the U.S.'s Only Successful Rebellion Since 1776 - Newsweek

Mr. President: We need to go.  It's time to give the ball to someone else - Instagram

‘The Life Ahead’ review: At 86, Sophia Loren is better than ever - NY Post

Woman Walks Nude Into Airport & Is Arrested. What Happened Next Was Worse. A Mother’s Struggle To Rescue Her Daughter - Pete Earley

Police, courts, and jails across the country are mishandling mental health crises.  Some states are making improvements.  Others not so much.

Philly Police Bodycam Footage Shows Walter Wallace Jr.'s Final Moments

"Much of the evening news conference, though, focused on changes to how Philadelphia Police will respond to mental health calls. The department and the city's DBHIDS pledged to be better coordinated, and will install a crisis-trained behavioral health specialist in the 911 dispatch center to help direct mental health providers to emergency calls that need them."

Gov. Northam signs laws advancing police, criminal justice reform in Virginia

Northam signs several bills, sends Va. budget back to legislators with redistricting amendment

"The bill is also named for Marcus-David Peters, a Black man who was shot and killed during an encounter with the Richmond police in 2018. Peters, a 24-year-old high school biology teacher and Virginia Commonwealth University alumnus, was naked and unarmed when he ran into traffic."

An alternative to jail for defendants with mental illness in Fairfax County

Warren Buffett's favorite market indicator nears record high, signaling stocks are overvalued and riskier than ever - Markets Insider

More ballots arriving in Georgia from overseas and provisional voters - AJC

Will absentee military votes deliver the coup de grace?

Biden Preaches Unity as Vote Counts Stall, Stops Short of Declaring Victory

Great message of unity and fair governance from Mr. Biden.  Please work for the bottom half regardless of skin color, background, and gender.

FCC forces T-Mobile to pay $200 million fine for subsidiary Sprint’s fraud - Ars Technica

Somewhere between cup and lip, federal subsidies for low-income callers slip into telecom ether.  Next?

Dead Souls | novel by Gogol - Britannica

All's well that ends well...Chichikov could make a bundle on Wall Street, then move on to stints on the Fed, at Treasury, and in Hollywood. 

Chinese regulators suspend record Ant Group IPO - Scott Tong/Marketplace

Ma, it turns out, still goes to work on Uncle Xi's farm...How will inevitable friction between high tech billionaires and the communist party shape Chinese capitalism?

Addicted to Identity Politics, Progressives May Miss a Historic Chance To Connect with America’s Working Class

Dear libtards: Why no blue wave? Here's one explanation.

Paths to US election victory: what Trump and Biden need to win - The Guardian

To: The righteous and desperate on both sides.

Brace yourselves.  Suffering a regime you can't stand 'til the next election is the ongoing test of democracy. 

Andrew Jackson's presidential victory in 1828 - Britannica

Populism?  Mr. Trump, you're no Andrew Jackson!  He won the most votes for president 3 times and worked to expand voting rights. 

After being ripped off in 1824 by the NE elites in House, Jackson won twice as many states extended voting rights beyond property owners.  Power to the American people!

Universal Male Suffrage: Impact on the 1824 Election

Voting Rights: A Short History

Andrew Jackson: Biography

" The Age of Jackson" - Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr.

Walmart abandons shelf-scanning robots, lets humans do work - AP/ABC

Could it be that some robots have become better at collective bargaining than low-paid American workers?  More specifically, the creators, lenders, manufacturers, repairers, and maintainers of capital may have many advantages over labor at the bargaining table with distributors of goods...Tired of dealing with these guys.  Scrap the bots...Humans may simply be better at finding sh-t other humans misplace than machines.

Facebook, Twitter and VC firms consider life outside Silicon Valley as they shift to remote work - CNBC

Will diaspora shift the relative cost of living in western states?

What low-wage workers need from the 2020 election - Fortune

Biden: at least $15/hour. Trump: not so much, not so fast.

Trump and Biden debate if it's time to raise the federal minimum wage - YouTube

The COVID-19 hazard continues, but the hazard pay does not: Why America’s essential workers need a raise - Brookings

West Virginia’s surprising boom, and bust, tells the story of Trump’s promise to help the ‘forgotten man’ - WaPo

Education, Employment, and Wages in the Appalachia Region - RAND

Low-Wage Living in the Pittsburgh region - Public Source

"We set out to hear the realities and perceptions of people working in low-wage industries in the Pittsburgh region. Here’s what we learned."

45 missing children found, 109 human trafficking survivors rescued in Ohio operation - CBS

'Rescued From Evil': 45 Missing Children Found, 109 Trafficking Survivors Recovered in Ohio

"There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one..."

China Leads Again - Stephen Roach

China's blend of capitalism and totalitarianism has provided a distinct advantage in managing the pandemic and its ecomomy - at least so far.  Can republic-based capitalist enterprise prevail in the recovery and longer run?  ...

Though President Trump is often accused of posing a threat to democracy, it is ironic that his laissez-faire approach to containing Covid-19 may be his political downfall.  During WWII, and other times of crisis, western republics have shifted more power to their chief executives to manage their economies in order to survive.

Is the battle now really between socialism and capitalism?  Or different forms of capitalism?  Can Chinese capitalism maintain is dynamism if it succeeds dominating international markets?  Can Western nations keep pace without a more disciplined approach to economic and domestic policies?  For example, in order to improve its economic performance, the U.S could take more forceful measures to contain Covid and expand health insurance coverage.

Marc Thiessen: Trump is one of the best conservative presidents in modern history — if you turn the sound off

If capable of articulating a coherent message of his administration's achievements and clear plan to deal with the pandemic, Trump might have had a lead coming up to election day despite his flaws of character.

No photo description available.

Trump’s Sour Grapes? Salma Hayek Apparently “Too Short” for Him

Get ready for some bizzarro spleen should DT lose. Chances of coup appear small. Hard to seize power on twitter, especially with large segment of senior military pissed off (the movie: "Seven Minutes in November").  Maybe just quit and let Mike run things for a few months.  What's next?  ... BTW its' not the first time Hayek has been mentioned on this site.

Fed adjusts terms of Main Street Lending Program to better target support to smaller businesses

A bit of powder left: Fed so far has loaned $3.7 billion of $75 billion in equity provided by the Treasury Department under the CARES Act.

This decade will likely be the first in at least 160 years in which American households have more people

The number of people in the average U.S. household is going up for the first time in over 160 years - Richard Fry/Pew Research

United States Housing Prices & Market - Redfin

"Home prices nationwide were up 14.4% year-over-year in September. At the same time, the number of homes sold rose 21.7% and the number of homes for sale fell 36.2%."

The Hottest Housing Markets Right Now In 2020 - Forbes

The 25 Cheapest U.S. Cities to Live In - Kiplinger

The Dark Side Of The Recovery Revealed In Big Data - NPR Planet Money

"First, the good news. With government assistance and a societal adjustment to how to live in a pandemic world, consumer spending has bounced back to about 95% of what it was before COVID-19 hit. Major corporations and all stripes of high-paid professionals have been able to adapt and even prosper in the coronavirus economy. The stock market is looking good. The housing market is looking good. For many Americans, the recession is over.

" 'Total high-income employment returned to its pre-pandemic level by the beginning of June,' Friedman says. 'So the recession was essentially over within a few months for high-income employees.'

"But the team's data show a completely different story for low-income workers. They make up the vast majority of the over 12 million Americans who remain unemployed. The job market for those making less than $27,000 a year is still down almost 20%."

Israel founders were ‘thieves’, Israeli historian says - Middle East Monitor


The Fed has done nearly all it can - and it's now up to Congress to further aid the economy: ex-N.Y. Fed president - Markets Insider

PHOTO: A maintenance man breaks the lock of a house as Maricopa County constable Darlene Martinez serves an eviction order on Oct. 1, 2020, in Phoenix.

A maintenance man breaks the lock of a house as Maricopa County constable Darlene Martinez serves an eviction order.

Photos document U.S. eviction crisis as families struggle during the pandemic - ABC News

While Washington waits for a political reset...

Big landlords move to evict thousands of tenants despite COVID ban - NY Post

Landlords, lobbyists launch legal war against Trump’s eviction moratorium, aiming to unwind renter protections - Washington Post

"Millions of U.S. renters face the renewed threat of eviction, according to housing advocates, who say the government has weakened its protections in response to recent lawsuits."

Protecting Renter and Homeowner Rights During Our National Health Crisis - National Housing Law

The Eviction Lab: Information and Resources

An analysis of Joe Biden’s tax proposals - Kyle Pomerleau/American Enterprise Institute

Leading conservative think tank estimates Biden's tax proposals would move trillions from top earning households to the bottom 95% with relatively minor +/- impacts on GDP.

"Key Points:

  • Using the Tax-Calculator (3.0.0) microsimulation model, we estimate that Joe Biden’s propos­als would raise federal revenue by $2.8 trillion over the next decade (2021–30).
  • The majority of new federal revenue would come from businesses and corporations ($1.9 tril­lion). The remaining revenue would come from individual income and payroll tax increases ($616.8 billion) and an increase in estate and gift taxes ($276.4 billion).
  • In 2021, Biden’s proposals would increase taxes, on average, for the top 5 percent of households and reduce taxes on households in the bottom 95 percent. In 2030, Biden’s proposals would increase taxes, on average, for households at every income level, but tax increases would primarily fall on the top 1 percent of income earners.
  • Using the open-source OG-USA (0.6.2) model, we estimate that Biden’s proposals would reduce gross domestic product (GDP) by 0.16 percent over the next decade, slightly increase GDP the second decade (0.19 percent), and result in a small reduction in GDP in the long run (0.18 percent)."

Labor Day is Every Day

U.S.Employment Gap Widens Between High- and Low-Income Workers - Opportunity Insights Tracker

The recession is over for the rich, but the working class is far from recovered - Heather Long/Washington Post

"The stock market and home values are back at record highs, while jobs remain scarce for those earning less than $20 an hour."

Domestic workers chart book: Economic Policy Institute

"A comprehensive look at the demographics, wages, benefits, and poverty rates of the professionals who care for our family members and clean our homes"

Comment: Excellent resource from the EPI...But too much emphasis on gender and race.  Left-wing think tanks could help low-wage workers more by stressing their common economic hardships rather than racial and gender differences.  Either through habit or demands by funders, looking at economic issues through the lens of identity politics has become a Progressive catechism ("Hail Mary".."Give us this day our daily bread.."). 

A Sea Change for Wages v. Capital?

Addicted to Identity Politics, Progressives May Miss a Historic Chance To Connect with America’s Working Class

Karl Polzer – Center on Capital & Social Equity

 New research affirms what has been known for centuries.  In the wake of a pandemic, a smaller, more risk-averse work force is often in position to demand higher wages.  After the Black Death ripped through Europe, for example, peasants, shop workers and craftsmen realized they had gained bargaining power.  Wages rose and the return on capital fell.

Though the impact of the current pandemic probably will be much milder, millions in the American working class suddenly deemed to be “essential” may come to a similar realization.  People working with their hands in nursing homes, grocery stores, meat packing plants, or as home health aides, might ask whether they are getting a fair deal.  Why, they might ask, are we expected show up to work and risk contagion for wages that barely cover the rent, while millions in the professional, management, and bureaucratic classes can shelter at home and still pull down a good salary?  Why don’t we get paid sick days, health insurance, and other basic benefits like they do?  Why can’t we spend more time raising our kids to help them get ahead?

In just two months, the Covid virus has upended the American workforce.  Incomes have crashed.   Unemployment has rocketed.   Whatever new normal emerges will be different and probably more unequal.  A larger portion of the workface – and the electorate -- may well be unemployed or working for low wages.  Jobs that can support a middle-class lifestyle may be harder to find. 

This is the perfect time for elected officials to talk to all American workers about how to improve their lives. Unfortunately, many Democrat leaders are deeply rutted in rituals of race and gender politics.  The Democratic party may be blowing its chance to regain working class support -- once its bread and butter -- in two important ways.   First, its policy agenda largely reflects upper-middle class priorities.  Second, the party’s world view and messaging for many years has presumed that low-wage work is exclusive to blacks and Hispanics.  To many Democratic leaders, pale-skinned poor people seem to have no standing.  It’s almost as if they don’t exist...

The response of real wages in Europe following pandemics

Longer-run economic consequences of pandemics? - Oscar Jorda, Sanjay Singh and Alan Taylor

Study finds pandemics are tend to be followed by periods of lower returns on capital and higher wages as surviving workers are left with increased bargaining power.

Making Sure We Get to Universal Coverage: a letter to Sen. Bernie Sanders

Feb. 23, 2020 

Dear Sen. Sanders,

Among all candidates for president, we think you are the most committed to making sure that ALL Americans have health insurance and access to comprehensive health care.  We commend you for your leadership on this issue.

Unfortunately, it is hard to see how the Medicare-for-all legislation you propose could gain Congressional approval in the foreseeable political future.  As a longtime member of the U.S. Senate, you must be able to understand the grounds for this concern.

Please answer this question:  If, during your presidency, Congress could agree to pass a universal coverage bill using a different, perhaps more traditional, approach, would you sign it?

Getting ALL Americans affordable coverage as soon as possible is an important part of our policy agenda.  We cannot wait until a political moment in the unforeseeable future in which a Medicare-for-all system can gain approval.  We also recognize that any universal system put in place will need to enjoy long-lasting acceptance spanning the ebbs and flows of partisan politics.

Our question is of deepest sincerity.  Your answer could be key to broadening your base of support and winning the presidency.

Thank you again for your leadership. 

Karl Polzer, Center on Capital & Social Equity

A Widening Gap in Life Expectancy Makes Raising Social Security’s Retirement Age a Particularly Bad Deal for Low-Wage Earners

Essay - Karl Polzer   

"Social Security’s long-term financial problems result in part from an increase in average life expectancy driven by wealthier people living longer, and, thereby, collecting more benefits.  Policymakers should not use funding shortfalls attributable these trends as an excuse to cut monthly benefits alike for those who have gained (high earners) and for those who haven’t (low earners)."

February 2020

Will Growing Inequality Make Social Security & Long Term Care Financing Fixes Harder?

2020 Society of Actuaries Living to 100 Symposium

June 2019

Mixing Capitalism and Socialism

Policies To Moderate Systemic Wealth Concentration in the United States

Karl Polzer/Center on Capital & Social Equity

This essay explores two basic questions.  The first is the extent to which capitalism, which emphasizes the rights of individuals to pursue their interests, and socialism, which focuses on group needs, tend to function in tandem as much as they do in conflict. As many agree that the political pendulum in recent decades has swung in favor of capitalism, the paper also discusses a range of public policies that can be used to reduce its imbalances and risks, with particular emphasis on moderating capitalism's tendency toward systemic inequality. Policy options range from programs to help the poorest, social insurance, higher taxation of income and wealth, and re-channeling to all citizens a portion of profits from private exploitation of public assets and business activities enabled by public laws and infrastructure.

Quick Links

Including all workers in our retirement savings system requires 2 things: a universal tax credit and a secure place to invest it.

Congress should be working on both.

Almost half of Americans have no net assets and little or no retirement savings.  Many have no money to save, and if they did, and no retirement account to put it in.  Meanwhile, Americans at the top of the economic heap get generous tax breaks for retirement savings – and capital gains from these assets widen the wealth gap.

Establishing a national retirement savings system and reshaping tax policy to provide every American worker a modest tax credit to put in a retirement account could improve economic security, help people prepare for old age, and facilitate saving for emergency expenses.  This type of inclusive capitalism would make every American worker an owner of assets generating income.  Such a system could be funded via a relatively small sacrifice to high earners without increased federal spending.  

Include Everyone in the Retirement Savings  System

Related initiatives and proposals:

If you know of other proposals along these lines or would like to comment, please go the "Contact Us" page on this site and send us an email. 

CCSE Proposes Universal Starter IRAs

Australia as a Model?

Australia’s “superannuation” system  requires employers to contribute a percentage of employees’ income into diversified retirement funds managed by trustees.  By 1999, 97 percent of Australia’s full-time employees and 76 percent of part-time employees were covered by the superannuation system.  Over the years, Australia has increased required contributions and continued to refine the system, which has been credited with raising levels of capital accumulation and improving retirement security.

According to a July 2016 report, the Australian superannuation system continues to broaden coverage, but may be contributing to growing wealth inequality in its current form.

CBO report shows growing divergence of wealth between those at the top and bottom

The distribution of wealth among the nation’s families was more unequal in 2013 than it had been in 1989, according a Congressional Budget Office report released August 2016. "For instance, the difference in wealth held by families at the 90th percentile and the wealth of those in the middle widened from $532,000 to $861,000 over the period (in 2013 dollars). The share of wealth held by families in the top 10 percent of the wealth distribution increased from 67 percent to 76 percent, whereas the share of wealth held by families in the bottom half of the distribution declined from 3 percent to 1 percent."

In 2013, CBO reported that families in the top 10 percent of the wealth distribution held 76 percent of all family wealth, families in the 51st to the 90th percentiles held 23 percent, and those in the bottom half of the distribution held 1 percent. Average wealth was about $4 million for families in the top 10 percent of the wealth distribution, $316,000 for families in the 51st to 90th percentiles, and $36,000 for families in the 26th to 50th percentiles. On average, families at or below the 25th percentile were $13,000 in debt.

Over the period from 1989 through 2013, family wealth grew at significantly different rates for different segments of the U.S. population. In 2013, for example: The wealth of families at the 90th percentile of the distribution was 54 percent greater than the wealth at the 90th percentile in 1989, after adjusting for changes in prices. The wealth of those at the median was 4 percent greater than the wealth of their counterparts in 1989. The wealth of families at the 25th percentile was 6 percent less than that of their counterparts in 1989.

While average wealth of the bottom quarter of the distribution dropped steeply over this time period, its amount of indebtedness grew significantly.

Research shows dramatic growth of upper middle class, major shift in economic resources

An Urban Institute report published in June 2016 found that since 1979 the percentage of wealthy and upper-middle-class Americans have grown dramatically while the middle- and lower-middle class has become smaller.  The study found that "the proportion of the population in the upper middle class went from under 13 percent in 1979 to over 29 percent in 2014."

The report documents a major shift in the distribution of economic resources. "In 1979, the bottom three income groups controlled 70 percent of all incomes, and the upper middle class and rich controlled 30 percent. By 2014, this distribution shifted to 37 percent for the bottom three groups and 63 percent for the upper middle class and rich groups. The middle class alone saw its share of income decline from 46 percent in 1979 to 26 percent in 2014."   

The study divides the population into five classes. The poor and the near-poor had annual incomes from $0 to $29,999; the lower middle class, from $30,000 to $49,999; the middle class, from $50,000 to $99,999; the upper middle class, from $100,000 to $349,999; and the rich, $350,000 and up. 

Pew study shows long-term decline in size of middle class, rise in number of poor

After more than four decades of serving as the nation’s economic majority, the American middle class is now matched in number by those in the economic tiers above and below it, according to a study released in December. In early 2015, 120.8 million adults were in middle-income households, compared with 121.3 million in lower- and upper-income households combined, according to the Pew Research Center analysis of government data.  Highlights include the following:

"While the share of U.S. adults living in both upper- and lower-income households rose alongside the declining share in the middle from 1971 to 2015, the share in the upper-income tier grew more.

"Over the same period, however, the nation’s aggregate household income has substantially shifted from middle-income to upper-income households, driven by the growing size of the upper-income tier and more rapid gains in income at the top. Fully 49% of U.S. aggregate income went to upper-income households in 2014, up from 29% in 1970. The share accruing to middle-income households was 43% in 2014, down substantially from 62% in 1970.

"And middle-income Americans have fallen further behind financially in the new century. In 2014, the median income of these households was 4% less than in 2000. Moreover, because of the housing market crisis and the Great Recession of 2007-09, their median wealth (assets minus debts) fell by 28% from 2001 to 2013.

"Meanwhile, the far edges of the income spectrum have shown the most growth. In 2015, 20% of American adults were in the lowest-income tier, up from 16% in 1971. On the opposite side, 9% are in the highest-income tier, more than double the 4% share in 1971. At the same time, the shares of adults in the lower-middle or upper-middle income tiers were nearly unchanged.

"These findings emerge from a new Pew Research Center analysis of data from the U.S. Census Bureau and the Federal Reserve Board of Governors. In this study, which examines the changing size, demographic composition and economic fortunes of the American middle class, ‘middle-income’ Americans are defined as adults whose annual household income is two-thirds to double the national median, about $42,000 to $126,000 annually in 2014 dollars for a household of three. Under this definition, the middle class made up 50% of the U.S. adult population in 2015, down from 61% in 1971."

Impact of Raising the Minimum Wage

Increasing the minimum wage would have two principal effects on low-wage workers, according to an analysis by the Congressional Budget Office.  Most of them would receive higher pay that would increase their family’s income, and some of those families would see their income rise above the federal poverty threshold. But some jobs for low-wage workers would probably be eliminated, the income of most workers who became jobless would fall substantially, and the share of low-wage workers who were employed would probably fall slightly.

  • Five Facts about the Minimum Wage.
  • Living Wage Calculator:  The cost of meeting basic needs varies widely depending on where you live. MIT offers an on-line tool to help determine such costs and the living wage in each county and metropolitan area in the U.S.  The site also has articles on related issues.
  • State Minimum Wage Levels:  Federal minimum wage law supersedes a state's minimum wage law if the state level is lower. In those states where the state minimum wage is greater than the federal level, the state minimum wage prevails. Two states have a minimum wage set lower than the federal minimum wage. In 29 states and DC, the state minimum wage is higher than the federal minimum. Fourteen states have a minimum wage that is the same as the federal requirement. The remaining five states have not established a minimum wage.

The Economics of Inequality

Deaton Wins Nobel Prize

"The award comes at a time when there is rising academic and popular interest in the study of inequality. Several economists, including Anthony Atkinson of the London School of Economics (who was among the leading contenders for a Nobel prize this year) and Thomas Piketty of the Paris School of Economics (who is still a bit too young for one), have published widely-read volumes on the subject over the last two years. Mr Deaton published his, The Great Escape: Health, Wealth, and the Origins of Inequality, in 2013. In it, he argued that while most people in the world have gained in terms of health and well-being from GDP growth over the last few decades, there are many groups that have missed out, particularly if on measures beyond those most commonly examined."

-- The Economist

Milanovic Explores Dynamics of Income Inequality in Age of Globalization

In “Global Inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization,” Branko Milanovic identifies five forces pushing up inequality in the United States:

1. The increasing share of national income that accrues to owners of capital.

2. Very high and rising concentration of incomes from capital.

3. People holding high-paying jobs also often have high capital income.

4. The tendency of high-income individuals to marry each other.

5. The rising political power of the rich.

Revisiting the work of American economist Simon Kuznets, Milanovic describes how global income economy waxes and wanes in "waves" driven by economic and political forces. 


CBO report analyzes impact of government transfers, taxes on rising U.S. income inequality

According to the June 2016 report

"Between 1979 and 2013, all three measures of income examined in this report—market income, before-tax income, and after-tax income—became less equally distributed, based on a standard measure of inequality known as the Gini index. The increase in inequality in both before-tax and after-tax income over the 35-year period stemmed largely from a significant increase in inequality in market income, mostly because of substantial income growth at the top of the market income distribution.

"Because government transfers go predominantly to lower-income households, before-tax income (which is equal to market income plus government transfers) was more evenly distributed in each year than market income. And because higher-income households pay a larger share of federal taxes than lower-income households do, after-tax income was more evenly distributed than before-tax income.

"In each year between 1979 and 2013, government transfers reduced income inequality significantly more than the federal tax system did."

 View from the Paris School of Economics


Lecture Highlights:

  • The return of a patrimonial (or wealth-based) society in the Old World (Europe, Japan).
  • Inequality in America: Is the New World developing a new inequality model that is based upon extreme labor income inequality more than upon wealth inequality? Is it more merit-based, or can it become the worst of all worlds?
  • In all nations with capitalist economies examined, the poorest half of the population owns virtually no assets or is in debt.
  • In general, when the rate of growth of capital exceeds the rate of growth of the overall economy, wealth tends to concentrate.  There is no natural market mechanism to counter this tendency; a nation's degree of wealth concentration in large part is a function of public policy.

"The Spirit Level: Why Greater Equality Makes Societies Stronger"

In this book, Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett present data making the case that countries with greater income inequality tend to have more health and social problems.  Furthermore, there is evidence that the negative effects of inequality impact not just the poor, but people at all social levels.  The Equality Trust provides slides of some of the supporting data.

This short Wall Street Journal video describes competing views of the wealth inequality issue and how to address it.

Thomas Piketty reviews Anthony Atkinson's book, Inequality: What Can Be Done? , and evaluates its prescription for Great Britain's economy.

Economists Discuss Atkinson's Ideas on Reducing Inequality

Robert Solow, the Russell Sage Foundation’s Robert K. Merton Scholar and Institute Professor Emeritus at MIT, joined New York Times columnist Paul Krugman and moderator Janet Gornick (Director of the Luxembourg Income Study Center and a former RSF Visiting Scholar) at the Foundation for a conversation on Inequality: What Can Be Done?, a new book by British inequality scholar Anthony B. Atkinson. In the book, Atkinson argues that economic inequality has reached unacceptable levels in many countries and lays out an agenda for reducing inequality. His policy proposals span five areas: technology, employment, the sharing of capital, taxation, and social security.

Columbia's Joseph Stiglitz takes on "The Great Divide"

Click on highlighted words to hear interview.

Hayek Revisited: Is Compromise Possible?

Is Friedrich Hayek's classic defense of individual liberty and economic freedom, rooted in moral tradition, just as relevant today as during World War II?  Click here to read a summary of Hayek's "The Road to Serfdom," published by Reader's Digest as that war came to an end and a new international economic order was developed. 

Today, how can monopoly power, whether wielded by corporations or government agencies, be checked while expanding economic opportunity and inclusion for all including the young, old, and those with few assets?  If Hayek could have foreseen the ability of  modern corporations to concentrate wealth and power, what policies would he recommend?       

"...Where, as in the case of sickness and accident, neither the desire to avoid such calamities nor the efforts to overcome their consequences are as a rule weakened by the provision of assistance -- where, in short, we deal with genuinely insurable risks -- the case for the state's helping to organize a comprehensive system of social insurance is very strong. ...

"(T)here is no incompatibility in principle between the state's providing greater security in this way and the preservation of individual freedom."

 --  F. Hayek, The Road to Serfdom, Chapter 9/Security  and Freedom

Center on Capital & Social Equity

2020 Policy Goals: Increase economic inclusion at reasonable public cost 

  • Raise minimum wage with annual COLA (option: give states some leeway to adjust ↓ to reflect cost of living/labor).
  • Five PAID sick days annually for ALL workers.
  • 100% of Americans with health coverage by 2025 - with strong cost controls (any number of payers will work).
  • Universal retirement savings system with minimum $500 annual government contribution (so, all Americans own working capital, have stake in market economy).
  • No surprise medical bill >$500.
  • Cut cost of college/expand apprenticeship programs.
  • Improve Social Security benefits for bottom 50%. Achieve long-term solvency through higher taxes mostly on top 20%.
  • Increase refundable child tax credit.

Life expectancy has not increased for the lowest-paid workers - National Academy of Sciences

Race-neutral, progressive economic policies deliver $$ to minority communities - Karl Polzer

"Although much of it may turn out to be pre-election packaging, legislation unveiled last week by Democrats to help racial minorities is a poorly conceived policy approach that fails to treat the nation’s low-wage workers fairly or equally.  Senate leadership is billing the Economic Justice Act as a “major new legislative proposal to make $350 billion in immediate and long-term investments in Black communities and other communities of color.”  However, policies that reward or punish citizens based on skin color not only rest of shaky legal and ethical ground.  If enacted, they may ignite a political backlash that will set minority communities back rather than helping them move forward."   

Click here to read article.

July 1, 2020

Letter to U.S. Political Leaders and Media

It’s past time the White House, Congress required - and funded - Covid testing in nursing homes

What wasn’t said at last week’s Congressional hearings on Covid-19 should raise alarm.   Federal officials testified the CDC plans to issue “more targeted” testing "guidelines" for states and nursing homes.  More advice is not enough.  After five months and more  than 120,000 virus deaths, lack of federal and state action -- and adequate funding -- for testing in nursing homes is homicide by negligent policy...

July 14, 2020

CMS to deliver ‘point-of-care’ COVID-19 test kits to all nursing homes

Yes!  Credit to CMS Administrator Verma and the Administration. We've been calling on the feds to deploy rapid, comprehensive testing for nursing home residents and staff for 4 months.  This is a major step toward reducing deaths from the pandemic.  Now, make sure to include long term care providers not directly regulated by CMS, such as assisted living facilities, in the testing program. About 1.5 million live in nursing homes and one million in assisted living.

June 15, 2020

Op-ed:Upgrade Medicaid, don't gut it - Karl Polzer

Thanks to the Washington Examiner for running this article.

"The current Medicaid regime is a mixture of bad and good. It often renders low quality nursing home care. But Medicaid does provide universal long-term care coverage, a rarity in American social policy. That’s a good thing. Medicaid needs to be upgraded – not gutted. Long-term care insurance and personal savings simply can’t fill the gap cutting Medicaid would leave." ...

"Witness the Trump administration’s delegation of most of the responsibility for the COVID-19 nursing home policy to the states. It recommended, for example, that states make sure COVID-19 testing gets done in nursing homes rather than having CMS require it nationally. Washington’s failure to take the lead on testing can’t bode well for nursing home quality and mortality rates."

Detroit Industry - Diego Rivera

The World Inequality Lab Newsletter - July 2020

Thomas Piketty - Why Capitalism Must Be Reformed | The Daily Social Distancing Show

Capital Gains and U.K. Inequality - Arun Advani and Andy Summers

Three policy recommendations include: "Capital gains tax rates need to be aligned more closely with marginal income tax rates, since large gaps lead to repackaging of income, reducing the redistributive effects of tax, creating horizontal inequity, and biasing measures of vertical inequality."

The Missing Profits of Nations: How much each country loses or attracts because of tax competition - Thomas Torslov, Ludvig Wier and Gabriel Zucman

June 2020

Opposing Racism and Human Bondage in the United States

 Center on Capital & Social Equity

Awakening Slaves - Michelangelo

"Capital and Ideology": Notes and Figures - Thomas Piketty, 2020

"In this talk, I present some of the figures & tables gathered in my book Capital and Ideology (2020) - an economic, social & political history of inequality regimes, from trifunctional and colonial societies to post-communist, post-colonial hyper-capitalist societies. As compared to Capital in the 21st Century  (2014): Capital and Ideology is less western-centered, more political and focuses on the fragilities and the transformation of inequality ideologies. A much better book (I believe!)"

The Saving Glut of the Rich and the Rise in Household Debt - NBER

Comment: Excellent new paper. Remember Macro 101: national savings = national investment?  This takes Keynes one step further. Instead of being invested, savings glut at top generates rents, increases systemic inequality, through increased lending to bottom 90%.  Who pays high credit card interest and transaction fees, and who profits, e.g.?

Great Flower Moon - Richard Coleman

Posted April 16, 2020 and updated as noted

Pinpointing Disease Pathways, Treatments: Which (If Any) of The Dots Connect?

Changes in blood chemistry - hypoxia - bloods clots - organ damage


COVID-19: Attacks the 1-Beta Chain of Hemoglobin and Captures the Porphyrin to Inhibit Human Heme Metabolism -ChemRxIV (April 13)

Heme in pathophysiology: a matter of scavenging, metabolism and trafficking across cell membranes

Hypoxia, such as encountered at high altitude, promotes deep vein thrombosis in mice

A Possible Explanation for the COVID-19 Racial Disparity — And a possible solution (posted April 19)

Doctors try to untangle why they're seeing 'unprecedented' blood clotting among Covid-19 patients (posted April 23)

New link between hypoxia and blood clot risk (posted April 23)

15 Children Are Hospitalized With Mysterious Illness Possibly Tied to Covid-19 (posted May 7)

Blood thinners may improve survival among hospitalized COVID-19 patients (posted May 8)r

COVID Hypoxemia: Finally, an Explanation — Mt. Sinai team uncovers a compelling mechanism (posted Sept. 9)

General Info

What Does It Mean to be Oxygen Deprived

U.S. races to stock up on dialysis supplies as kidney failure ravages virus patients – Politico  Approximately 20 percent of coronavirus patients in intensive care around the city need the kidney treatment, often for weeks.

Coronavirus destroys lungs. But doctors are finding its damage in kidneys, hearts and elsewhere

Doctors keep discovering new ways the coronavirus attacks the body (posted May 11)

Obese COVID Patients More Likely to Have Pulmonary Embolism, Even Outside the ICU (posted June 3)

Cheap drug has been helping to save lives of COVID-19 patients (posted June 18)

More Data Suggest Proning Helps COVID-19 Patients (posted June 18)

More covid-19 patients are surviving ventilators in the ICU (posted July 4)

RECOVERY: Steroid Benefit in Severe COVID-19 Holds Up -- Sickest patients helped the most, drug already added to NIH guidelines (posted July 18)

Common steroids reduce deaths among critically ill Covid-19 patients, new analysis confirms - CNN (posted Sept. 3)


Autopsies Turn Up Strange Feature of COVID-19 Lungs — Study finds more thrombi and a new puzzle in the vessels (posted May 27)


Hypoxia: The Force that Drives Chronic Kidney Disease

Sense of Smell

The Effects of Hypoxic Hypoxia on Olfactory Sensitivity in Humans

Letter to the Washington Post, Other Media - April 3, 2020

U.S. news media should make coronavirus coverage available to everyone

The Washington Post and other newspapers have done yeoman work in covering the coronavirus outbreak. Getting reliable and thoughtful information to the public quickly plays a critical role in helping to coordinate responses and saves lives. Unfortunately, the normal practice of restricting access to paid subscribers slows down dissemination of critical information, particularly to lower-income people.

Until this national emergency is over, the Post and other media should "ungate" all coverage related to the pandemic. That way people and organizations that subscribe can quickly get the word out about latest developments. This would be a great service to the public.

Karl Polzer/Center on Capital & Social Equity

Anchored Boats (1919) by Jonas Lie

March 3, 2020   -   Letter to the Washington Post 

A wealth tax could be both fair and enforceable

 The Post’s March 3 article “Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren want a wealth tax. Wealthy Swiss say their model could work for America” raises key issues of tax fairness and enforcement.

 Why would it be unfair to tax the super wealthy on total net assets when middle-class homeowners already are taxed on the value of homes largely financed through debt on which they pay interest to banks (whose profits flow disproportionately to the wealthiest)?   Existing American wealth taxes -- state and local property taxes -- now finance most K-12 education.  A national wealth tax could be used to make school funding more equitable and lessen the tax burden on the middle class.  We already tax the middle class on property it partially owns.  So why not tax the wealthiest on the value assets they own lock, stock and barrel?

 Incentives are key to enforcement.  A progressive wealth tax -- rising in increments from point A to point B -- could be enforced by applying the maximum rate to all households with wealth over a given threshold, and leaving it up to filers to document to the IRS that the lowest allowable rate is appropriate.  Finally, a reasonable tax rate could provide an incentive for investment that spurs economic growth.  A high rate could stifle it.

Karl Polzer/Center on Capital & Social Equity

A full time worker paid the federal minimum wage earns 13% of the average national income per worker in the US -- the lowest level since the creation of the minimum wage in 1938.

   Source: Gabriel Zucman.

"Fastest way to cut carbon emissions is a 'fee' and dividend, top leaders say," Washington Post, 2/14/20

The article above is an example of how the virtue of economic analysis can't be measured by the pound or aggregate number of titles. The insight of a single analyst can contain more wisdom than collective opinion of 100.

Response to WaPo  dialogue stemming from our letter on carbon taxes

Dear Washington Post Editors:

Sabrina S. Fu made excellent points in her Feb. 4 letter “Quit saying ‘carbon tax.’ It’s a fee and dividend” addressing concerns I raised in a letter last week.  Her proposal, however, would work best an ideal political world where one can control opponents' and skeptics' language used to frame an issue.   My concern over tax fairness would remain because in the legislative bargaining process -- including a last-minute deal in conference committee -- the redistribution part of the proposal could easily be watered down, or eliminated, while the regressive "tax" or "fee" would become law.

Why don’t we start by applying her proposal to the current gasoline tax?  If it survives the legislative process and works for current energy taxes, then move on to carbon writ large.  Bottom line: advocates for low- and middle-income people trying to survive today need to keep a sharp eye on idealistic proposals coming from the better-situated trying to save the planet in the next century.

 Karl Polzer

Center on Capital & Social Equity


Aug. 7, 2019

By letting banks charge excessive credit card fees, US raises prices for all, shifts billions of $$$ to the wealthier

Karl Polzer

There are many mechanisms through which the financial establishment systematically drains money from workers struggling to pay their bills.  Some hum along in plain sight while regulators and members of Congress barely take notice.  Such is the case with the $80 billion in fees that banks will extract from credit and debit card transactions this year.  

While other countries have lowered credit card transaction costs, either through non-bank market innovation (in China) or regulation (in the European Union, Australia, and other nations), U.S. policymakers empower banks and credit card networks to levy what amounts to a doubly regressive national sales tax...

(Also see the note on excessive credit card interest rates beginning on p. 6.)

A winner for the poor? Soda machine offers lower price for cash in Poulsbo, WA

Photo by Tom Hahler

Letter to Washington Post - Nov. 17, 2019

The Post’s call for vigorous debate on capitalism raises issue of its role as honest broker

Today’s lead editorial (“Capitalism itself is on the 2020 ballot: Every billionaire is not a policy failure, but each can afford to pay more”) begins by defending core values of capitalism. It then endorses higher taxes on the super wealthy to temper growing inequality.  On the critical issue of how much more wealthy people should pay toward government operation and programs, the editorial is silent.  It ends with a call for vigorous and informed debate over these critical issues during the 2020 election.

Along the way, by carefully acknowledging that its current owner, Jeff Bezos, bought the Post from the “civic minded” Graham family six years ago, the editors raise another important issue.  That is whether one of the world’s most influential sources of news and public opinion can maintain both neutrality and vigor in the debate over capitalism if owned by one of the world’s richest people.  As the debate deepens, this potential conflict of interest may become more awkward and harder to explain. 

Karl Polzer, Founder, Center on Capital & Social Equity

Saez/Zucman's "The Triumph of Injustice: How the Rich Dodge Taxes and How To Make Them Pay"

Branko Milanovic's "Capitalism, Alone"

Map of golf clubs in and around San Francisco

Ways To Replace the "Cadillac" High-Cost Health Plan Tax

click below

Warning: Read the article above at your own risk. Author declaims any responsibility for variation in sense of humor. Note that some links in this article are intended to provide useful information, others irony.

NRA HQ in the Northern Virginia suburbs.

States strike back in federal court on AHPs

CCSE asked to co-sign amicus brief opposing U.S. Labor Dept.'s AHP rule, which increases risk of stripped-down benefits (e.g. no mental health coverage), healthplan insolvency, and consumers being defrauded.

Effects of Raising the Federal Minimum Wage

Congressional Budget Office - July 2019

Findings: "In an average week in 2025, the $15 option would boost the wages of 17 million workers who would otherwise earn less than $15 per hour. Another 10 million workers otherwise earning slightly more than $15 per hour might see their wages rise as well. But 1.3 million other workers would become jobless, according to CBO’s median estimate. There is a two-thirds chance that the change in employment would be between about zero and a decrease of 3.7 million workers. The number of people with annual income below the poverty threshold in 2025 would fall by 1.3 million." … Similar, but smaller effects for minimum wage of $12 … Ditto for $10 minimum wage.

MIT Living Wage Calculator Provides Powerful Tool for State and Local Policymakers

Many U.S. households earning less than a living wage: MIT analysis

"Across all family sizes, the living wage exceeds the poverty threshold, often used to identify need. State minimum wages provide for only a portion of the living wage. For two adult, two children families, the minimum wage covers 73.0% of the living wage at best in the District of Columbia and 41.8% at worst in Virginia. This means that families earning between the poverty threshold ($25,298 for two working adults, two children on average in 2018) and the living wage $67,146) on average for two working adults, two children per year before taxes), may fall short of the income and assistance they require to meet their basic needs."

Example: Maryland is one of the wealthiest states in the U.S., but income varies widely by region. This has made it difficult for the legislature to set a uniform minimum wage.

Possible option: Set a statewide minimum wage at $15/hour (or other level) and let local governments reduce it up to a fixed percentage (say 30%) to account for regional differences. It's important to index any minimum to inflation.

Joseph Stiglitz discusses his new book and "progressive capitalism" plan to rebuild America’s middle class on SalonTV.

If crimes against children can’t be stopped from within, the Vatican & its subsidiaries need purging from the outside: Letter to Washington Post

Every Catholic and every U.S. citizen should carefully read The Post’s Feb. 20 front-page article “ ‘The tragedy that keeps playing out.’ ” It is the latest in an endless stream of detailed evidence that the church power structure is incapable of changing from within to protect children in its care from sexual abuse. Senior church officials should be charged with criminal negligence for failing to remove predators they employ from positions from which they could injure children. Billions of dollars should be removed from the Vatican and its subsidiaries through the courts and distributed to victims. Still, would they change their ways?

Until this systemic problem is forcibly corrected, every church, school and other Catholic facility whose employees come into contact with children should undergo thorough inspection every year on the presumption that abuse may be occurring. If this cannot be corrected from within, then the Catholic Church should be broken up and reorganized. The same should happen with any church operating this way. Jesus commands that those in power do not harm those in their care, particularly children.

America: Build This Wall! :)

 The stand off over building a border wall sadly embodies the narrow-mindedness of America’s leaders and disrespects the creative potential of American capitalism.  It’s an undeniable fact that Donald, Chuck and Nancy are thinking way too small to discern the proper dimensions of a win-win agreement that could profit the United States for centuries...

Distribution of Household Income before/after Transfers and Taxes: CBO

Summary of slides released November 2018

In 2015, household income was unevenly distributed: Households at the top of the income distribution received significantly more income than households at the bottom of the distribution.

Before accounting for the effects of means-tested transfers and federal taxes:

  • Average income among households in the lowest quintile (or fifth) of the income distribution was about $20,000.
  • Average income among households in the highest quintile was about $292,000.
  • Within the highest quintile, income was highly skewed toward the very top of the distribution: Among households in the bottom half of the highest quintile (the 81st to 90th percentiles), average income was $157,000; among the 1.2 million households in the top 1 percent of the distribution, it was $1.9 million.

The combined effect of means-tested transfers and federal taxes in 2015 was, on average, to increase income at the bottom of the income distribution and decrease income at the top of the distribution.

After accounting for the effects of means-tested transfers and federal taxes:

  • Average income among households in the lowest quintile of the income distribution was about $33,000.
  • Average income among households in the highest quintile was about $215,000.
  • Among households in the bottom half of the highest quintile, average income was $125,000; among households in the top 1 percent, it was $1.2 million.

Below: Taxes, transfers resulted in significantly more income growth from 1979-2015 for the bottom income group than the middle three, while the top income group was held harmless.

Would Adam Smith favor policies creating a more inclusive economy?

Karl Polzer Center on Capital & Social Equity

In a recent op-ed, I suggested that Congress establish a universal retirement savings system, possibly funded by a tiny tax on financial market transactions. In another, that growing income and wealth inequality has shrunk Social Security’s revenue and that taxing capital gains and high earnings could help the program stay solvent without cutting benefits.  What would Adam Smith, the father of modern economic analysis, think of taxing financial transactions and capital gains?  The notion of including all workers in saving and ownership of working capital?  Helping correct the tendency of modern capitalism to concentrate wealth?  Although conservative economists often cite Smith as a siren of an unfettered market, he might give these proposals serious consideration.  Times have changed.  Yet his manner of reasoning remains vital in addressing issues we face today.

Milanovic previews 'Capitalism, alone'

Policy ideas:

  • "Improved quality of education and much easier access to education for all—that is, investing for stronger public education rather than the opposite trend of ever stronger private education.
  • "Deconcentraton of ownership and income from capital through the use of tax incentives, a long and arduous process.
  • "Employee stock ownership plans.
  • "Higher taxation of inheritance (not current income).
  • "Change in the rules re. financing of political campaigns (especially in the United States)."
Growing inequality has shrunk Social Security’s tax base. Revitalizing it could restore solvency without cutting benefits.

As the graying and outsized baby boom generation claims Social Security benefits, Americans increasingly doubt whether the program can pay all that it has promised – or even continue to cut checks at all.  In their annual report released June 5, Social Security’s Trustees warn that, unless Congress acts to restore the program’s long-term solvency, by 2034 it will only have sufficient funds to pay 77 cents of each dollar currently promised. By then, the Social Security trust fund will be empty and the program will lack legal authority to pay out more than it can bring in through earmarked taxes. An adjustment this size in 2018 would drop the average annual  Social Security payment of $16,848 to $12,973. Most older Americans depend on Social Security for all or most of their income. 

The longer Congress plays chicken on this issue, the greater the risk that changes such as tax increases or benefit cuts, or a combination, will have major economic impacts on retirees and workers. The trustees’ report emphasizes the growing ratio of retirees receiving benefits to workers contributing payroll taxes as a major force impinging on the program’s solvency. Underlying factors include the size of the baby boom generation and a lower birth rate.  But other forces are at work.  Growing wealth and income inequality have significantly eroded Social Security’s tax base.    

First, wealth inequality: As Americans at the top of the economic spectrum continue to amass equities, bonds, and other assets, the portion of national income from capital investment has increased significantly, pushing down the portion earned through labor.  In the United States, labor’s share of earnings fell about eight percentage points between 1995 and 2013 (compared to a bit over three percentage points in other Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development countries).  Since Social Security relies primarily on a tax on labor for its sustenance, the relative growth of capital income gradually is choking off a source of revenue.  

Second, income inequality: As part of its structure to promote fairness between economic classes, Social Security replaces relatively more lifetime income for lower-wage workers than those with higher wages – but also caps wages subject to its payroll tax, in part to increase the net value of Social Security in the eyes of higher earners.  The wage cap for 2018 is $128,400.  Over the past several decades, wages of lower-income Americans have stagnated, while those at the top have grown significantly.  As a result, the trustees note that portion of wage income taxed by Social Security has dropped by about six percentage points (see p. 144). In agency jargon, the “taxable ratio” of payroll fell from 88.6 percent in 1984 to 82.6 percent in 2000, and has fluctuated near the latter level since then. Social Security Administration (SSA) actuaries assume the ratio will remain about 82.5 percent over the next decade.  In summary, unless the tax cap on earnings keeps up with the growing prosperity of those at the top, Social Security’s tax base shrinks as a portion of national income.

America's Inequality and What To Do about It

The Poor Will Always Be with Us. Will the Middle Class?

Why the Wealth Gap Hits Families the Hardest - NYT

"The top 1 percent saw their wealth increase by 156 percent (from 1989 to 2013), while parents in the bottom half saw their wealth shrink by 260 percent. About a third of all families with children in 2013 had no wealth, only debt."

"Rising Inequality and the Changing Structure of Political Conflict" - Piketty lecture at the Kennedy School

Extreme Income Inequality: Brazil, India, the Middle-East and South Africa

This paper presents findings about inequality dynamics in Brazil, India, the Middle-East and South Africa by combining tax data, household surveys and national accounts.

In all of these four regions, top 10% earners receive more than 50% of national income. These societies are characterized by a dual social structure, with an extremely rich group at the top whose income levels are broadly comparable to their counterparts in high-income countries, and a much poorer mass of the population. The authors highlight the importance of the historical legacy of social segregation and of modern institutions in shaping income disparities.

Which Way Is Your Country Headed?

Analysis including Housing Assets Finds Piketty May Have Underestimated Wealth Gap

The Rate of Return on Everything - CEPR

"One of the most intensely debated economic questions in recent years is the relationship between real returns on wealth, and the real rate of growth. In his influential book, Piketty (2014) argued that if the return to capital exceeded the rate of economic growth, rentiers would accumulate wealth at a faster rate than incomes grow. Comparing returns to growth, or “r minus g'' in Piketty's vernacular, we uncover that in fact “r >> g” for more countries, more years, and more dramatically than Piketty himself reported."

These two figures show that the only exceptions to “r>>g” happen in very special periods: the years in or right around wartime. In the pre-WW2 period, r minus g was on average 5% per annum (excluding WW1). As of today, this gap is still quite large – in the range of 3%–4% – and it narrowed to 2% during the 1970s oil crises, before widening in the years leading up to the Global Crisis.


"We show that income inequality has increased in nearly all world regions in recent decades, but at different speeds. The fact that inequality levels are so different among countries, even when countries share similar levels of development, highlights the important roles that national policies and institutions play in shaping inequality."

How Humans Extract Rent from Nature's Gifts

"As soon as the land of any country has all become private property, the landlords, like all other men, love to reap where they never sowed, and demand a rent even for its natural produce. The wood of the forest, the grass of the field, and all the natural fruits of the earth, which, when land was in common, cost the labourer only the trouble of gathering them, come, even to him, to have an additional price fixed upon them. He must then pay for the licence to gather them, and must give up to the landlord a portion of what his labour either collects or produces. This portion, or, what comes to the same thing, the price of this portion, constitutes the rent of land, and in the price of the greater part of commodities, makes a third.” 

― Adam SmithWealth of Nations

This chart shows that collective income accruing to India's “middle 40” rose to just over 45 percent by the early 1980s, while that of the top 10 percent declined from about 37 percent in 1951 to 30 percent. After 1990 the two trends reverse. The top 10 percent garnered more than 55 percent of all income in 2014, almost double its share in the early 1980s, while the middle 40 percent’s share fell to just over 30 percent.

U.S. Tax Policy Should Boost Retirement Savings for All Workers, Not Just the Wealthiest

Center on Capital & Social Equity - October 2017

Current tax breaks for retirement savings mainly subsidize the top half of the income distribution, leaving almost half the workforce out of the system. Part of the federal tax subsidy for 401(k)s should be rechanneled into a retirement savers tax credit that all workers get ($500 to $1,000 a year).

In 2017 employees can put up to $18,000 in tax-deferred defined contribution plans (e.g., 401(k)s) and those 50 or older can put aside an additional $6,000. Total employee and employer contributions are limited to $54,000. The Tax Policy Center estimates that in 2016 the tax savings from all tax-qualified pension and defined contribution accounts averaged about $1,040 per taxpayer. (No kidding: 1040.) These tax savings, however, were extremely tilted toward the well-off. Only 4.4 percent of workers in the lowest fifth of the income distribution received any tax benefit and their average tax savings in 2016 was $20. In contrast, 82 percent of the highest-paid quintile received a tax benefits with an average benefit of $4,750. About 48 percent of the middle fifth received a tax benefit with an average savings of $580.

The result of this tax policy? About half the American population has put aside virtually nothing for retirement, while many wealthy people are being paid to save money they would have saved anyway. It’s clear that retirement savings tax breaks could be better targeted.  For more information see:

Atlas freed?

"Worry not at all about inequality if it is achieved by smart betterment....But do worry about inequality if it is achieved by using the government to get protection for favored groups.  It is what a large government, worth capturing to get the protection, is mainly used for, to the detriment of most of the people off-stage."

Are Workers Receiving the EITC Being Shortchanged on Social Security?

updated October 2017

..."Under the current system, a person whose highest earnings averaged $15,000 a year over 35 years would end up with about $10,542 in annual Social Security benefits – the same as a worker averaging $15,000 wages plus various amounts of EITC.  A worker averaging $20,000 in wages would end up with $1,600 (15%) more in annual Social Security benefits compared with another with the same total income but instead averaging $15,000 wages and taking home $5,000 in EITC.  Similarly, someone averaging $25,000 in wages would end up with $3,200 (30%) more in Social Security benefits than a counterpart averaging $15,000 and receiving $10,000 in EITC."

Green lines: current law    Purple: proposed increases 

D's Push for Major EITC Expansion

September 2017

Two members of Congress are teaming up to bring much-needed relief to low-wage workers and their families through an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC).

Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH) and Representative Ro Khanna (D-CA) introduced the  Grow American Incomes Now (GAIN) Act in both the House and Senate. Currently, a family of three can receive a maximum EITC of $6,318, while workers without dependent children can receive at most a $510 credit.  The legislation would roughly double the EITC for eligible workers raising children and increase the credit for workers without dependent children nearly six fold. The bill also lowers the qualifying age for the EITC from 25 to 21.

CCSE comment:

Expanding the EITC is a good idea. However, as the share of workers' income provided by government subsidies rises, the case becomes stronger for the federal government to begin making corresponding payments to Social Security.  Also, a way to simplify tax policy might be to coordinate the EITC and Child Tax Credit (CTC) in the following way: the EITC could be based solely on income, not family structure. The refundable component of the Child Tax Credit could be expanded to provide additional income for low- and middle-income families.

September 2017 - Karl Polzer

Expanding Use, Scope of the EITC & Child Tax Credit: a Win-Win for Workers and Employers

This paper makes the case that helping employees access the Earned Income Tax Credit and Child Tax Credit – along with supporting bipartisan legislation to expand these programs – can help industries with large numbers of low-to-middle wage workers. In the long-term care field, such a strategy can improve worker income through government wage supplements, thus encouraging more to enter the workforce. Increased labor supply would dampen employer wage costs – all while expanding the range of affordable services providers can offer. This could result in hundreds of millions of dollars of added value in worker earnings as well as provider and customer savings.

From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia 1905-2016

"...(T)op  income  shares  are  now  similar to (or  higher than) the levels observed in the U.S.  ... inequality  has  increased substantially more in Russia than in China and other ex-communist countries in Eastern Europe. ...the wealth held offshore by rich Russians is about three times larger than official net foreign reserves, and is comparable in magnitude to total household financial assets held in Russia."

High earnings of labour are an advantage to the society - Adam Smith

“Is this improvement in the circumstances of the lower ranks of the people to be regarded as an advantage or as an inconveniency to the society? The answer seems at first sight abundantly plain.  Servants, labourers and workmen of different kinds make up the far greater part of every great political society.  But what improves the circumstances of the greater part can never be regarded as an inconveniency to the whole.  No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable.  It is but equity, besides, that they who feed, cloath and lodge the whole body of the people, should have such a share of the produce of their own labour as to be themselves tolerably well fed, clothed and lodged.”

-- The Wealth of Nations (originally published in 1776)

A Life Lived in Truth

For the last eight years of Liu Xiaobo’s life, the Chinese authorities robbed him of his liberty and his dignity. But in the state-enforced silence surrounding Liu’s stage-managed death, the words of his Nobel Prize lecture ring out even louder: “Freedom of expression is the foundation of human rights, the source of humanity, and the mother of truth.”

Warren Buffett: Government Should Do More on Income Inequality - short video

"Natural forces of a market economy and capitalism will drive that disparity unless government does things to help." Buffett says EITC should be expanded so workers can have decent lives. (See CCSE article on this site about relationship of EITC and Social Security.)

Capital Accumulation, Private Property and Rising Inequality in China, 1978- 2015

Thomas Piketty, Li Yang, Gabriel Zucman

Researchers find that the share of public property in China'snational wealth has declined from about 70% in 1978 to 30% in 2015...

"The top 10% income share rose from 27% to 41% of national income between 1978 and 2015, while the bottom 50% share dropped from 27% to 15%. China’s inequality levels used to be close to Nordic countries' and are now approaching U.S. levels."

Robin Hood Tax Reform - May 2017

How Modest Changes in Health, Retirement Tax Breaks Could Produce Major Gains in US Health Access, Financial Security – at Little or No Added Government Cost

..."The positive impacts of two such changes discussed below could include 1) lowering the rate of health care cost inflation; 2) providing revenue to help subsidize health insurance for the unemployed; 3) creating seed money and a low-cost infrastructure for a universal retirement savings system; and 4) increasing retirement security for low- and middle-income people; and 5) helping people save for long-term care costs. Looking at benefit tax exclusion is already on the table as Congress faces the unsavory chore of developing a fix for the Affordable Care Act’s clumsily designed “Cadillac” health plan excise tax. Most importantly, these changes could result in greater economic fairness and inclusion."

Eyes on the Prize: Universal Health Insurance Is the Goal

Letter to the Washington Post:

Charles Krauthammer’s March 31 op-ed, “The road to single-payer health care,” was largely on point. However, it is important to separate the concepts of “single-payer,” which is a means toward a goal, and “universal coverage,” which should be the primary goal. Universal coverage can be achieved without having the government cover every citizen. Even if government programs cover most citizens, there will always be multiple payers, including individuals and taxpayers; a universal system also could allow employer plans to operate. Ironically, creating a larger government role in sponsoring and subsidizing health insurance could result in a more competitive market for providing services.   Karl Polzer - April 2, 2017

Reformed Tax Incentives Among Tools Needed To Boost Retirement Saving

David Kamin of NYU law school presents proposed changes at the Aspen Institute.

updated Dec. 14, 2016

Obama Signs Bipartisan Bill To Speed Miracle Cures to Market.  Who Will Have Access to the New Technology?  Who Won’t?

In a city that’s witnessed trench warfare between Congress and the White House during the last six years of the Obama Administration, this was a rare moment: a bipartisan love fest.  On Dec. 13, 2016, President Obama signed the "21st Century Cures Act," which includes expanded funding to push medical technology through the development pipeline. “We are bringing to reality the possibility of new breakthroughs to some of the greatest health-care challenges of our time,” Obama said. “It is wonderful to see how well Democrats and Republicans in the closing day of this Congress came together around a common cause.”

The legislation was backed by a coalition of interests, including the powerful pharmaceutical industry, academia, and consumer groups supporting speedier medical research.  Its few critics have mainly argued that the popular funding provisions “mask a worrisome loosening of regulations at the Food and Drug Administration that could put patients at risk.”

Hardly anyone, however, is asking the million-dollar question:  Which Americans will end up having access to new miracle cures, many of which promise to be extremely expensive?  And, who will not?  The country’s patchwork of health insurance already is rationing expensive new technology to some populations, particularly low-income people.  Congress, meanwhile, has begun a fractious debate over repealing, and possibly replacing, the Affordable Care Act (ACA).  So, while lawmakers have just put their collective foot on the technology gas pedal, they may soon slam the brakes on funding for expanded coverage, potentially throwing millions of Americans into the ranks of the uninsured...              

Traditions of Democracy

    "The tradition of Jefferson and Jackson might recede, but it could never disappear.  It was bound to endure in America so long as liberal capitalistic society endured, for it was the creation of the internal necessities of such a society.  American democracy has come to accept the struggle among competing groups for the control of the state as a positive virtue -- indeed, as the only foundation for liberty.  The business community has been ordinarily the most powerful of these groups, and liberalism in America has been ordinarily the movement on the part of other sections of society to restrain the power of the business community.  This was the tradition of Jefferson and Jackson, and it has been the basic meaning of American liberalism."  

Excerpt from Chapter 37, "The Age of Jackson," Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr.

Federal Reserve researchers probe economic inequality, policies that could spread U.S. income gains

The increase in U.S. income inequality since 1970 has generated large welfare gains for households in the top 20% of the income distribution and significant welfare losses for those in the bottom 80%, according an analysis published by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.  The modeling found that some of the impact of this upward income shift was mitigated by "the dramatic rise in government redistributive transfers, which have doubled as a share of U.S. output over the same period."

The analysis concludes:  "Alternative simulations imply that a relatively modest boost in the historical growth rate of government redistributive transfers, accompanied by modestly higher average tax rates, could have achieved small but equal welfare gains for all households. Overall, our results suggest that there is room for policy actions that could offset the negative consequences of rising income inequality."

June 30, 2016

Reflections on American Wealth Concentration – and What To Do About It

Just over one year ago, the Center on Capital & Social Equity (CCSE) began exploring the phenomenon of growing wealth concentration and inequality, while advocating for a more inclusive form of capitalism. Following are some general observations.

Over the past year, the issue of economic inequality in the United States has moved from the backburner to center stage. Much credit for this goes to Sen. Bernie Sanders’ attack on the “top one percent” in his run for the Democratic nomination. While there is ample reason to question many details of his proposals, Sanders’ call for an increased role for government in providing opportunity and essential services resonated with many Americans who feel they have been left out of the economic mainstream. Yet the problems posed by rising economic inequality are deeply rooted and go well beyond the disproportional gains of the top one percent. They will be harder to address than portrayed in election rhetoric and require judicious use of public resources.

Three observations can be made about economic inequality in the United States. First, income and wealth inequality have grown steadily since the 1980s, suggesting that some of the causes are structural in nature. Second, high levels of inequality increase the risk of political and economic instability. Finally, moving toward an economy that is less unequal and offers opportunity to more Americans will require major changes in public policy and shifts in spending.

Life Expectancy Gap is Large - and Expanding

The gap in life expectancy between the richest 1% and poorest 1% was 14.6 years for men and 10.1 years for women.  A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association also found that inequality in Americans' life expectancy is growing over time.

How the U.S. Retirement Savings System Magnifies Wealth Inequality

Karl Polzer, Center on Capital & Social Equity 

Economic inequality and wealth concentration have have emerged as central issues in the U.S. presidential race. While these concerns appear to have risen to the forefront quite suddenly, forces driving wealth concentration have been building for decades. As analysts probe the dynamics beneath these trends, they may find that America's shift to a defined contribution retirement system is playing an increasing role in the concentration of wealth... 

So, What Does Jesus Say about Wealth Concentration and Inequality?

Karl Polzer 

In recent years, the tendency for wealth to concentrate in the hands of a powerful few has come under scrutiny, prompting concern about growing inequality from political and religious leaders, most notably Pope Francis. While excessive wealth concentration is likely lead to greater social ills and unrest, how to rein in growing inequality is a more difficult question.  Should we move away from capitalism and the market system?  Develop a more socialist model?  Reform capitalism from inside to benefit people more equitably? ... 

Virginia's push to end veteran homelessness faces steep challenges

On Nov. 11, 2015, Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe announced that the state was the first to "functionally" end homelessness among veterans of the U.S. armed forces.  To assist two veterans living on the street not aware of the program, the Center on Capital & Social Equity contacted the governor's office, asking how veterans can gain access to housing and other services under the collaboration involving state, federal, and local government agencies.

The Virginia Department of Veterans Services provided information (click on the button below), including contact points at the local and state levels where veterans and their advocates can begin the process of finding temporary or permanent housing.

To follow up, we contacted three Northern Virginia jurisdictions and found an array of barriers to functionally ending veteran homelessness.  These problems include lack of  knowledge on the part of local officials of the state's initiative; lack of affordable and subsidized housing resources; high housing prices; lack of shelter space (for example, Fairfax County has 1 million residents but only three homeless shelters that can't meet wintertime demand); unwillingness by many street people to seek help (for a variety of reasons); coordination issues between state and local, local and local, and federal and state and local agencies; bottlenecks like having to go through shelters to gain access to housing, when shelter space is limited; and many other factors.

While helping one of the veterans gain access to temporary shelter and services, we reported these issues back to the state officials who said they will take steps to increase awareness of the governor's initiative, including posting information about the program on a state website.  For more detail, see our correspondence with state and local officials, which can be accessed by clicking the second button below.

Let’s sell health insurance “across states lines” – through Medicare

Republicans, stop with being the party of “no.” It’s time to step up to the plate and seize the initiative on health policy...

Playing Immigration Piñata

Deception and hypocrisy are no strangers to politics. This seems particularly true in recent incantations about illegal immigration. Republican presidential candidates – other than Jeb Bush – mostly want to round up illegals and dump them into Mexico. Donald Trump wants to spend billions to build a massive wall in the wrong place...

How Can U.S. Policy Reduce Financial Risk for the Very Old?

CCSE explores ways to reduce retirement risk and pay for long term care in Society of Actuaries monograph.

Finding:  401(k)rule changes including new "sub-accounts" could help seniors better save for needs in very old age.

Retirement Strategy:  When Should I Start Receiving Social Security Checks?

Americans can begin taking Social Security between ages 62 and 70. Waiting to take Social Security can increase the amount on your check significantly.  Collecting Social Security benefits early has the opposite effect. 

When to start depends on many factors including your life situation,  needs and plans.  Most Americans begin taking Social Security early.

The U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau offers this planning tool and other information to help people work through this decision.   

Baltimore 2015

A Dream Deferred

by Langston Hughes

What happens to a dream deferred?

Does it dry up
like a raisin in the sun?
Or fester like a sore--
And then run?
Does it stink like rotten meat?
Or crust and sugar over--
like a syrupy sweet?

Maybe it just sags
like a heavy load.

Or does it explode?

Still I Rise

You may write me down in history
With your bitter, twisted lies,
You may tread me in the very dirt
But still, like dust, I'll rise.

Does my sassiness upset you?
Why are you beset with gloom?
'Cause I walk like I've got oil wells
Pumping in my living room.

Just like moons and like suns,
With the certainty of tides,
Just like hopes springing high,
Still I'll rise.

Did you want to see me broken?
Bowed head and lowered eyes?
Shoulders falling down like teardrops.
Weakened by my soulful cries.

Does my haughtiness offend you?
Don't you take it awful hard
'Cause I laugh like I've got gold mines
Diggin' in my own back yard.

You may shoot me with your words,
You may cut me with your eyes,
You may kill me with your hatefulness,
But still, like air, I'll rise.

Does my sexiness upset you?
Does it come as a surprise
That I dance like I've got diamonds
At the meeting of my thighs?

Out of the huts of history's shame
I rise
Up from a past that's rooted in pain
I rise
I'm a black ocean, leaping and wide,
Welling and swelling I bear in the tide.
Leaving behind nights of terror and fear
I rise
Into a daybreak that's wondrously clear
I rise
Bringing the gifts that my ancestors gave,
I am the dream and the hope of the slave.
I rise
I rise
I rise.

Maya Angelou

Easter Essay: Is the Golden Rule Enough? Mathematics of the Two Great Commandments

Whether people see themselves as Christians, followers of other faiths, or atheists, all are pulled by the power of many gods: the god of money, the god of technology, the nymph of new electronic gadgets, satyrs of TV and the worldwide net, and so on. In adoration of possessions, money, and power, atheists and believers are equal -- even deeply religious in the way that Paul sarcastically described the polytheistic statuary of Athens as evidence of its faith. Some of today’s humanists and atheists are more Christian in spirit and behavior than nominal Christians. And, unlike some Christians, many have thought through their views on religion and feel they need to have moral justification they can explain. The conventional morality of good people often is a humanism expressed by the Golden Rule.

Jesus taught the Golden Rule two thousand years ago, as one of two great principles. But to Jesus the Golden Rule, while essential, is incomplete without a first principle. Jesus preached the Golden Rule in the Sermon on the Mount. "Therefore, whatever you want men to do to you, do also to them, for this is the Law and the Prophets." (Mat 7:12 NKJV).) Here he is speaking to a large crowd that can't hear him that well and needs a simple guideline.

Later, speaking to religious leaders, he aligns the Golden Rule with the first commandment. In Matthew 22:34-40, "hearing that Jesus had silenced the Sadducees, the Pharisees got together. One of them, an expert in the law, tested him with this question: ‘Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?’ " To this audience, Jesus provides more context: "'Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.' This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: 'Love your neighbor as yourself.' All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments."

The interaction of the two great commandments shows why the second commandment is not sufficient and why God -- an overarching Spirit that connects individual people -- is necessary, even for a functional morality. For example, if we only love our neighbor as ourselves -- and we happen to be filled with hate and rage for ourselves -- then we won't treat our neighbors very well. The Golden Rule can remedy part of this problem by changing the focus from "loving" to "treating" neighbors as we would have them treat us -- thereby imposing our view of ideal behavior and not raw emotion as the standard. But that won't work for some people either, especially those who lack a model of ideal behavior. So, these folks still might act destructively to people around them.

The idea of a single God, or life force, connecting all people creates a vertical pull toward a connecting spirit (the first commandment) to accompany the horizontal equity of the second commandment. Mathematically, the second commandment is nothing more than a simple equation: Love for me = Love for you. The first commandment is a command to maximize Love to the limit of capacity. Without the first commandment, the potential of a person's love would be limited by inherited and culturally absorbed defects and injuries. The two commandments can be seen as consistent with scientific theories of evolution. The first commandment reflects the biological imperative that no individual can carry on life on his or her own. Individuals must interact and communicate with others to continue the stream of life. The Golden Rule suggests that individuals have the freedom to choose the way they interact and communicate with others. Perhaps those with greater faith and sense of fairness are more likely to pass along their genes. --

Karl Polzer, Easter 2017 

"In God We Trust" was adopted as the official motto of the United States in 1956 as an alternative or replacement to the unofficial motto of E pluribus unum, which was adopted when the Great Seal of the United States was created and adopted in 1782. Secularists have expressed objections to its use and have sought to have the religious reference removed from the currency.  Wikipedia, 2015


Join Us

We invite you to join the discussion.